‘We won’t drop Brad Hill’: Speedster emblematic of St Kilda’s problems

Last year, Hill played every game yet didn’t finish in the top 10 in the best and fairest. The rest of the foreign legion brought in at the end of ’19 (Jones, Dougal Howard, Paddy Ryder and Dan Butler) all outperformed him.

There was a school of thought that after a year of building chemistry with his new teammates, coupled with a return to longer quarters, Hill would again find the form that made him a star at Fremantle. That form has been largely elusive, and Ratten conceded the speedster wasn’t working hard enough.

Saints coach Brett Ratten, pictured, conceded Hill wasn’t working hard enough.Credit:Getty Images

“[His workrate] was down. Hilly’s a proud person and he’ll bounce back. At times he had to work harder. That wasn’t just him. You can’t just categorise him because there was a few others in that boat as well.”

Clearly, the Saints’ ruck situation has been a major problem for them to this point of the season. Rowan Marshall and Ryder have played just one game between them so far in 2021. Hunter has proven to be a great story of persistence, making his AFL debut at 28, but he has been found badly wanting in his three appearances.

The ruck nadir for Ratten appeared to be Richmond’s third-quarter dominance out of the middle, despite the fact Damien Hardwick was employing the 184-centimetre Marlion Pickett to give Toby Nankervis a chop out.

“With all respect to Pickett, rucking, but he’s not a ruckman. So we had an advantage that we could have taken in the centre and we were losing centre bounce clearances probably as much anything else, and the ball was just going their way. That was very, very disappointing. We missed Marshall tonight, there’s no doubt about it, and we missed Ryder. But Marshall will be back next week and Paddy might be a week or two away. So we’ve got to do something about it,” Ratten said.

Loading

Marshall (foot) and Jones (managed) were both close to being picked for the Richmond game – coming off a five-day break – and are due back for next weekend’s date with Port Adelaide, while Ryder should also play at some stage in the next fortnight. Jimmy Webster (groin) is likely to miss a week.

Will Ratten make a statement at selection? Part of the problem is the options are limited. Youngster Ryan Byrnes is a player Ratten said he is keen to have another look at, but the pacy onballer is only just returning via the VFL on Friday following a major hamstring injury.

McKernan and Wood too are ideally only backups and struggled in the first few weeks of the season to both be on the outer by mid-April.

“It’s a bit like snakes and ladders, isn’t it? We move forward three steps and then we go backward five. So we can’t pick and choose,” Ratten said.

“Footy’s a funny game. We’re definitely not where we want to be. We’ll cop the hits, and we should cop the hits for that performance again.

“It’s nearly the same sort of message from two weeks ago. We have to rebound here and there’s a lot of footy to be played.”

Real Footy newsletter

Keep up to date with the best AFL coverage in the country. Sign up to receive our newsletter twice-weekly during footy season.

Daniel is an Age sports reporter