Tavistock gender clinic facing legal action over ‘failure of care’ claims
Tavistock #Tavistock
The Tavistock gender identity clinic is facing legal action over claims children were misdiagnosed and rushed into transitioning at a young age.
The clinic, which is being shut down by NHS England, was criticised by an independent review for the quality of care and services provided to patients, who were predominantly young teenagers expressing an interest in gender transitioning.
Staff, patients and parents have raised concerns that young people using the service were put on the pathway to transitioning too early and before they had been properly assessed.
It is alleged children were “rushed into taking life-altering puberty blockers without adequate consideration or proper diagnosis”, with staff under pressure to adopt an “unquestioning affirmative approach”.
Mass legal action is now being pursued by lawyers against the clinic, named the Gender and Identity Development Service (GIDS), which has treated 19,000 children with gender dysphoria since 1989.
Lawyers at Pogust Goodhead have accused the clinic at the Tavistock and Portman NHS Trust of “failures in their duty of care towards young children and adolescents”.
Head of product liability, Lisa Lunt, said: “While the provision of gender dysphoria treatment for children and young adolescents, where appropriate, is an important service, many have been let down by Tavistock and Portman NHS trust.
“We support the findings of the Cass Review, Interim Report and believe there has been a real level of harm that has been perpetrated towards patients who were rushed into taking life-altering puberty blockers without adequate consideration or proper diagnosis”.
Tom Goodhead, chief executive of Pogust Goodhead, said he expected at “least 1,000 clients will join this action”.
He added: “These children have suffered life-changing and, in some cases, irreversible effects of the treatment they received which has resulted in long-term physical and psychological consequences for them.”
GIDS questioned the scale of the looming legal action and highlighted that around 1,000 patients have been referred to its endocrinology teams, to access hormone suppressants, over the past decade.
Pogust Goodhead said the allegations of negligence are likely to be based on numerous supportive findings from the Cass review, not just the alleged rushed use of puberty blockers.
The allegations of medical negligence are based on the findings of an interim report by Dr Hilary Cass, a former president of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, who is leading a review of the service.
The Cass review was commissioned in September 2020 amid the rise in demand, long waiting times for assessments and “significant external scrutiny” around GIDS’ approach and capacity, the NHS said.
It concluded that the service was struggling to deal with spiralling waiting lists, was not keeping “routine and consistent” data on its patients, and found that health staff felt under pressure to adopt an “unquestioning affirmative approach”.
A tanker from Thames Water delivers a temporary water supply to the village of Northend in Oxfordshire, where the water company is pumping water into the supply network following a technical issue at Stokenchurch Reservoir
PA
Students (from left) Sophie Thwaites, Aaliyah McLaine, Michael Stewart, Aaron Boyack and Claire McNab at Auchmuty High School in Glenrothes, Fife, check their results as high school pupils across Scotland find out their exam results
PA
James Willstrop and Declan James of Team England compete with Adrian Waller and Daryl Selby of Team England during the squash men’s doubles gold medal match on the last day of the Commonwealth Games
Getty
Ojie Edoburun of England takes the gold medal in the 4×100 Men’s Relay on Day 10 of the Commonwealth Games in Birmingham
EPA
People walk on parched ground in Greenwich Park in London
EPA
England’s Anthony Harding and England’s Jack Laugher competes to win and take the gold medal in the men’s synchronised 3m springboard diving final on day eight of the Commonwealth Games at Sandwell Aquatics Centre in Birmingham, central England
AFP/Getty
The Top Secret Drum Corps from Switzerland during the working rehearsal for this year’s Royal Edinburgh Military Tattoo, entitled Voices, at Redford Barracks, Edingburgh
PA
England’s Emily Campbell celebrates after winning gold in the women’s 87+kg weightlifting at the Commonwealth Games
Getty
Circus company Lost in Translation show off some tricks at the top of Calton Hill in Edinburgh
Getty
England’s players celebrate during a victory party in Trafalgar Square in central London
AFP/Getty
England’s striker Chloe Kelly celebrates after scoring her team second goal during the UEFA Women’s Euro 2022 final football match between England and Germany at the Wembley stadium
AFP/Getty
People during Belfast Pride parade which returns to the city for the first time since the pandemic
PA
Maxwell Tall, 2, cries as Mayor of London Sadiq Khan speaks to the media during a visit to Mums for Lungs community group in South Woodford, London, to coincide with the final day of the ULEZ expansion consultation and the publishing of new air quality data
PA
Liz Truss during a visit to a broadband interchange company in Leeds, as part of her campaign to be leader of the Conservative Party and the next prime minister
PA
A person waits for a train at Kings Cross Station as union members take part in a fresh strike over jobs, pay and conditions
PA
Lavender is harvested at Lordington Lavender farm near Chichester, West Sussex
PA
Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer and shadow chancellor Rachel Reeves (left) view a robot during a visit to the Manufacturing Technology Centre at the Liverpool Science Park, as part of a two day visit to the city
PA
Emma Parfett and Shaun Smith paddle in the sea during the Whitby Steampunk Weekend in Yorkshire
PA
Members of environmental groups including Just Stop Oil, the Peace and Justice Project and Insulate Britain take part in a mass protest, in Parliament Square in London
AP
Traffic queuing to check in at the port of Dover on the A2 as holiday makers struggle to get away
SWNS
Tory leadership candidate Liz Truss meeting staff and children during a visit to the charity Little Miracles in Peterborough
PA
The chard remains of homes in the village of Wennington after the heat triggered a series of blazes across the UK
Tom Maddick/SWNS
Britain’s Jake Wightmancelebrates after winning the 1500m at the World Athletics Championships in Eugene, Oregon
EPA
A police officer givers water to a soldier wearing a traditional bearskin hat, on guard duty outside Buckingham Palace. The government issued their first-ever red warning for extreme heat
AP
Cameron Smith kisses The Claret Jug on the 18th green after he won The 150th Open at St Andrews Old Course
R&A via Getty
Ministry of Fun skaters during the annual International Busking Day event at Wembley Park, London
PA
Ellen White, Millie Bright, Beth Mead and Rachel Daly celebrate with the fans after England beat Northern Ireland in their last Euro 2022 group match in Southampton
Getty
Actor Kevin Spacey leaves the Old Bailey in London, he is charged with sexual offences against three men. The 62-year-old is accused of four counts of sexual assault and one count of causing a person to engage in penetrative sexual activity without consent
PA
Batonbearer, diver Sebastian Prajsnar carries the Queen’s Baton for the Birmingham 2022 Commonwealth Games, in the aquarium at The Deep, sealife attraction in Hull as the baton visits the Yorkshire region during its 25-day tour of England in the final countdown to the games
PA
A general view of cracked earth with the houses of Parliament and the Elizabeth Tower, more commonly known as Big Ben, seen behind as hot weather continues
Reuters
A man swims in the Sky Pool, a transparent swimming pool suspended 35 meters above ground between two apartment buildings, during hot weather in Nine Elms, central London
PA
Winner Novak Djokovic and runner up Nick Kyrgios following the Men’s Singles Final at The 2022 Wimbledon Championships
Getty
People enjoy the warm weather on Southsea Beach in Hampshire
PA
Alfie Hewett celebrates winning his match against Gustavo Fernandez in their Gentlemen’s Wheelchair Singles semi-final match at Wimbledon
PA
Prime Minister Boris Johnson addresses the nation as he announces his resignation outside 10 Downing Street
Getty
England players celebrate after winning their opening match of the Women’s Euro against Austria
Reuters
British Culture Secretary Nadine Dorries, British Brexit Opportunities and Government Efficiency Secretary Jacob Rees-Mogg, British Attorney General Suella Braverman and British Chief Whip Chris Heaton-Harris attend the weekly Cabinet meeting at Downing Street in London
Getty
Australia’s Nick Kyrgios celebrates winning against US Brandon Nakashima at the end of their round of 16 men’s singles tennis match on the eighth day of the 2022 Wimbledon Championships at The All England Tennis Club in Wimbledon
AFP/Getty
Fields of borage in flower turn the landscape purple near Feering in Essex
PA
Pride parade in London
Getty
Supporters of Wikileaks founder Julian Assange protest outside the Home Office in London to mark his birthday.
PA
The Prince of Wales, known as the Duke of Rothesay while in Scotland, and The Princess Royal after attending the Order of the Thistle Service for the installation of The Right Honourable Dame Elish Angiolini and The Right Honourable Sir George Reid, at St Giles’ Cathedral, Edinburgh
PA
Angela Rayner, deputy leader of the Labour party, speaks during PMQs
UK Parliament/AFP/Getty
Rafael Nadal attempts to reach the ball during his first round Wimbledon match against Francisco Cerundolo
Reuters
The cleaning up begins after the Glastonbury Festival at Worthy Farm
EPA
Paul McCartney, from left, Dave Grohl and Bruce Springsteen perform at Glastonbury Festival in Worthy Farm, Somerset
Joel C Ryan/Invision/AP
The crowd watching Wet Leg performing on the Park Stage during the Glastonbury Festival at Worthy Farm in Somerset
PA
An aerial view of the Glastonbury Festival site
James Dadzitis/SWNS
Festivalgoers on the first day of Glastonbury Festival
EPA
A general view of an empty platform at Paddington Station in London, as members of the Rail, Maritime and Transport union begin their nationwide strike in a bitter dispute over pay, jobs and conditions
PA
Following the closure of the Tavistock clinic, new regional centres will be set up to “ensure the holistic needs” of patients are fully met, the NHS has said.
It comes amid a sharp rise in people seeking GIDS’ help over the past decade, jumping from 250 in 2011 to 5,000 referrals in 2021, according to the service’s statistics.
In her review, Dr Cass said having one clinic was not “a safe or viable long-term option”.
New centres, one based in London and the other in the northwest of England, are due to open in spring 2023.
A spokesperson for Tavistock and Portman NHS Trust said: “GIDS has not heard from Pogust Goodhead about this matter, but it would be inappropriate to comment on any current or potential legal proceeding.
“The service is committed to patient safety. It works with every young person on a case-by-case basis, with no expectation of what might be the right pathway for them, and only the minority of young people who are seen in our service access any physical treatments while with us.”
Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism
By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists
Already have an account? sign in
Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism
By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists
Already have an account? sign in