NFL Week 15 overreactions, reality checks: Time for Falcons to fire Arthur Smith? Jets sit Aaron Rodgers?

Week 15 in the NFL certainly focused on the playoff races. Six teams entered the weekend tied for the No. 6 playoff spot in the AFC while five teams were tied for the No. 7 spot in the NFC. Let’s not forget the three teams tied for first in the NFC South.

The Sunday afternoon slate of games certainly created some narratives as the league heads into Christmas week. Those logjams in the conference playoff races got a little clearer as well. 

With playoff races as hot as ever, there were plenty of overreactions to go around. Which are actually overreactions and which are reality? 

Arthur Smith should be fired as Falcons head coach

Overreaction or reality: Reality

Losing to the Panthers is unacceptable, period. The Falcons had the benefit of playing the Panthers in the NFC South this week in what should have been one of the easiest wins of the year against a struggling team. Instead, Atlanta lost to Carolina despite the defense not giving up a touchdown.

The misusage of Kyle Pitts (four targets) and Drake London (three targets) is baffling. Let’s not forget Bijan Robinson getting only seven carries. These are all first-round draft picks Smith doesn’t utilize in his offense. 

The Falcons are 20-28 under Smith, never winning more than seven games in a season in the poor NFC South. Time to move on. 

Saints are going to win the NFC South

Overreaction or reality: Overreaction

The Saints are the best of the three teams in the NFC South hunt, yet haven’t shown it over the course of the season. New Orleans beat up on a bad New York Giants team, giving the Saints two convincing wins against bad teams (outscored the Giants and Panthers 52-12). 

Due to the Saints’ inconsistencies throughout the year, it’s hard to determine whether this team will win the division yet. New Orleans plays the Los Angeles Rams next week before facing the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in Week 17 in a game that likely will determine the division. 

Derek Carr tossed three touchdown passes for the first time this season and the Saints have averaged 26.7 points over the last three weeks. New Orleans looks like the best team in the division, but the Saints still have a lot to prove. 

Overreaction or reality: Reality

Houston is currently the No. 8 seed in the AFC playoff race, tied with the Cincinnati Bengals and Indianapolis Colts record-wise. Due to tiebreakers, the Bengals and Colts are ahead of the Texans. Houston struggled to score points without Stroud on Sunday in its overtime win as the offense didn’t score a touchdown until 3:03 left in the fourth quarter.

The defense against the Tennessee Titans is what kept the Texans in the game. Case Keenum also didn’t have Nico Collins and Tank Dell at wide reciever either, putting Houston in a hole in the passing game. Keenum deserves credit for keeping the Texans afloat in the playoff race, but this team isn’t making the playoffs in a crowded AFC wild card hunt without Stroud at quarterback. 

Houston has the Cleveland Browns and Indianapolis Colts in the final three weeks, as both teams are ahead of them in the wild card standings. Having Stroud return in time for next week would be massive. 

Jets should tell Aaron Rodgers not to play this year 

Overreaction or reality: Reality

Being eliminated from playoff contention, what’s the point of Rodgers returning and risking further injury to his Achilles? While it’s incredibly impressive Rodgers is practicing and can be ready to play 15 weeks after rupturing his Achilles, playing him is a major risk for a team that has nothing to play for. 

Perhaps Robert Saleh plays Rodgers in a last-ditch effort to save his own job. The Jets can eliminate that theory by saying Saleh will return as head coach next year no matter how their lost season plays out. 

While it would be fun to see how Rodgers looks over the final three weeks, the Jets need him to compete and win a Super Bowl in 2024 (especially with that defense). Playing Rodgers isn’t worth it for the Jets long term. 

New York’s season is over. Just play out the string with Zach Wilson, Trevor Siemian or whoever. The Cleveland Browns — who play the Jets in Week 17 — would certainly appreciate it.