Manchester United vs. Villarreal player ratings: De Gea awful in PKs as Yellow Submarine win Europa League
De Gea #DeGea
The Europa League trophy went to Villarreal on Wednesday after an instant classic as the Yellow Submarine beat Manchester United in the final on penalty kicks, 11-10. The match ended at 1-1 after regulation, and neither team could get the winner in extra time. Goalkeeper Geronimo Rulli was the hero, scoring the winning penalty and saving David De Gea’s attempt to give the club its first European trophy.
But how did each player perform in this one? Here are our player ratings for the match for every starter, substitute and manager.
All ratings are out of 10, and the higher the number the better. A zero would be a first-minute red card. A 10 would be a historic dominant hat trick.
Craving even more coverage of the world’s game? Listen below and follow ¡Qué Golazo! A Daily CBS Soccer Podcast where we take you beyond the pitch and around the globe for commentary, previews, recaps and more.
Villarreal ratings
(GK) Geronimo Rulli
120
Truth be told, he had very little to do outside of the penalty kicks. But he deserves a world of credit for his brilliant finish and then stopping De Gea. An instant club legend.
8
(DEF) Juan Foyth
88
Really great energy and patience but took a nasty knock early that left him bloody. The fight was there, though sometimes the technical ability wasn’t.
6
(DEF) Raul Albiol
120
The veteran defender timed his aerial attempts well and was the leader at the back, as usual. At 35, he’s still delivering.
7
(DEF) Pau Torres
120
Had some really strong moments, using his strength to keep United’s big boys at bay. It’s no wonder why so many big clubs want him. A star in the making who took his PK with class.
8
(DEF) Alphonso Pedraza
88
Tried to do too much at times, and it left him exposed, but United’s attack was so poor that really it didn’t make an impact at all.
6
(MID) Dani Parejo
120
A little sloppy early but came up big in the first half with a lovely assist to Gerard Moreno on a free kick. His patience on the ball frustrated United.
7
(MID) Etienne Capoue
120
Tremendous effort, physical play and just really never looked gassed when he was needed. A fine shift, though it was far from flashy.
6
(MID) Manuel Trigueros
77
Got himself in good spots to block efforts but hardly got involved going forward. Not his best day, but he’ll take it.
5
(FWD) Gerard Moreno
120
⚽ 29′ Delivered a big goal in the first half with a lovely finish from a set piece and scored his penalty. The big clubs are going to come calling.
7
(FWD) Carlos Bacca
60
A quiet performance from the Colombian. He had a rabona cross, but that was pretty much it. Taken off in the second half.
4
(FWD) Yeremi Pino
77
The young talent showed flashes but was hardly a factor, going off in the second half.
5
Francis Coquelin
Bacca (60′)
Came on to help defensively in the middle and earns another trophy.
6
Paco Alcacer
Pino (77′)
Never got a chance in attack but bagged his penalty well.
6
Moi Gomez
Trigueros (77′)
Decent shift from the veteran, putting away his penalty and playing with a calmness.
7
Alberto Moreno Pedraza (88′) Took his penalty beautifully, and he didn’t make a mistake in defense. 6 Mario Gaspar Juan Foyth (88′) Came off the bench, held his own in extra time and scored his penalty. 6
Unai Emery
5
Another success in this competition, getting a major trophy and qualifying for the Champions League. They were the better team and fully deserving.
9
United ratings
David De Gea
120
Left high and dry by his defenders on Moreno’s goal, but was otherwise untested. Got nowhere near the penalties and was sadly the fall guy who missed his.
3
Aaron Wan-Bissaka
120
Solid defensively, but not nearly accurate enough going forward and delivering the ball in attack.
5
Eric Bailly
116
Still rusty and looked awkward early on, but adapted better than many before running out of steam against his former club.
6
Victor Nelson Lindelof
120
Scored his penalty, but few will forget his lightweight attempt to deny Moreno on the Villarreal goal.
5
Luke Shaw
120
Fortunate with his penalty and perhaps fortunate to have stayed on considering that he was not his usual self and was caught out for the goal.
5
Scott McTominay
120
Tried to keep United pushing forward, but equally wasted a good opportunity of his own.
6
Paul Pogba
116
Needed to be deployed further forward and fizzled out after a bright start before being withdrawn.
4
Mason Greenwood
100
Arguably United’s most impressive performer and was full of energy as he tried to make things happen before he was surprisingly substituted first.
7
Bruno Fernandes (c)
120
Waited for his penalty to do something meaningful and otherwise shied away from the occasion while wearing the armband from the off.
4
Marcus Rashford
120
Hard to disguise his awful showing with his penalty perhaps the only salvation other than his minor role in Cavani’s goal.
2
Edinson Cavani
120
⚽ 55′ Scored the equalizer and converted his penalty, but United failed to build on his goal.
6
Fred
Mason Greenwood
Showed his nerve from the spot after coming on in extra time.
6
Axel Tuanzebe
Eric Bailly
Lovely penalty, even if that was not what he was sent on for.
6
Daniel James
Paul Pogba
Another substitute who successfully scored his penalty.
6
Juan Mata Aaron Wan-Bissaka Likewise, tactically subbed on as penalties loomed and converted. 6 Alex Telles Scott McTominay Sent on to score from the spot and he did. 6
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer
Five
No changes over 90 minutes. Recalled Rashford for a stinker and should have kept Greenwood on for longer.
3