December 26, 2024

Fact Check: Did Missile Hit Poland Instead of Kyiv After Coordinates Typo?

Poland #Poland

Zelensky Calls For Investigation Into Poland Missile Strike

SHARE

SHARE

TWEET

SHARE

EMAIL

What to watch next

  • What To Know As Large Rail Union Rejects Deal, Renewing Strike Possibility

    What To Know As Large Rail Union Rejects Deal, Renewing Strike Possibility

    Newsweek

  • Watch As An Orca Attacks A Boat

    Watch As An Orca Attacks A Boat

    Newsweek

  • Dog Messes Up Home While Owner Was In Meetings

    Dog Messes Up Home While Owner Was In Meetings

    Newsweek

  • Jennifer Lopez Posts Loved Up TikTok With Ben Affleck

    Jennifer Lopez Posts Loved Up TikTok With Ben Affleck

    Newsweek

  • See Adorable Baby Bengal Tigers Play Together

    See Adorable Baby Bengal Tigers Play Together

    Newsweek

  • Iran National Anthem Booed By Own Fans At England World Cup Match

    Iran National Anthem Booed By Own Fans At England World Cup Match

    Newsweek

  • What We Know About Colorado Springs Shooting And Suspect Anderson Aldrich

    What We Know About Colorado Springs Shooting And Suspect Anderson Aldrich

    Newsweek

  • Viral Videos Of Astronauts Falling Over On The Moon

    Viral Videos Of Astronauts Falling Over On The Moon

    Newsweek

  • Watch The Official Trailer For Netflix's 'Wednesday Addams'

    Watch The Official Trailer For Netflix’s ‘Wednesday Addams’

    Newsweek

  • Zelensky Vows to Take Back Crimea Amid Kherson Offensive: 'This Is Ours'

    Zelensky Vows to Take Back Crimea Amid Kherson Offensive: ‘This Is Ours’

    Newsweek

  • Who Is Bob Iger? Ex-Disney Boss Returns In Shock Appointment

    Who Is Bob Iger? Ex-Disney Boss Returns In Shock Appointment

    Newsweek

  • Thousands Watch How To Make 'Juicy' Turkey In An Air-Fryer For Thanksgiving

    Thousands Watch How To Make ‘Juicy’ Turkey In An Air-Fryer For Thanksgiving

    Newsweek

  • Queen Elizabeth II In Quotes

    Queen Elizabeth II In Quotes

    Newsweek

  • Ecuador Fans Chant 'We Want Beer' in Protest at Qatar’s World Cup Ban

    Ecuador Fans Chant ‘We Want Beer’ in Protest at Qatar’s World Cup Ban

    Newsweek

  • Jennifer Aniston Reveals Fertility Struggle: 'It Was Really Hard'

    Jennifer Aniston Reveals Fertility Struggle: ‘It Was Really Hard’

    Newsweek

  • Elton John's Final U.S. Performance Is Streaming On Disney+

    Elton John’s Final U.S. Performance Is Streaming On Disney+

    Newsweek

  • Click to expand

    UP NEXT

    UP NEXT

    The U.S. and Ukraine were at odds over a missile strike that killed two people in Poland, with Kyiv initially claiming the explosion was caused by Russia despite NATO’s assertion it was an accident.

    Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelensky said at a press conference he had “no doubt that it was not our missile,” a message later contradicted by U.S. President Joe Biden, who told reporters at the White House “that’s not the evidence,” per CNN.

    Amid the confusion and fingerpointing, however, posts have appeared on social media which allege that the cause of the attack may have been a typing error by artillery target coordinators.

    The Claim

    A number of social media posts from November 16 to 18, 2022, suggest that the map coordinates of Przewodów, the Polish village where a missile hit, have the same longitude as Kyiv and the latitude of Lviv.

    Eastern European news account Visegrád 24 tweeted: “The missile which killed 2 Poles landed in Przewodów, Poland: 50.47099 lat, 23.93432 lon. The location has the latitude of Kyiv and longitude of Lviv. It’s possible someone might have entered the wrong coordinates in a case of erroneous targeting.”

    The tweet generated more than 5,000 engagements.

    The Facts

    Newsweek Fact Check was able to independently verify that Przewodów, Kyiv, and Lviv share similar coordinates on their x and y-axis.

    According to latlong.net, an online geographic tool that can be used to lookup latitude and longitude of a place, and source its map coordinates, central Kyiv’s GPS coordinates are 50.4501 and 30.5234, while Lviv’s are 49.8397, 24.0297. The location of the missile strike in Przewodów was around 50.474582, 23.923020, next to a farm in the village.

    Changing the latitude in Lviv or the longitude in Kyiv with the corresponding Przewodów coordinates does indeed support the possibility of a coordinates mix-up, as the posts suggest.

    However, the conclusion derived from this observation appears to be entirely speculative.

    It’s true that Russia targeted Ukrainian cities, including Kyiv and Lviv recently, and hypothetically could have mistakenly targeted Przewodów in the barrage.

    A Reuters report from March, citing U.S. officials, suggested that Russia has suffered failure rates of up to 60 percent, while some of its more recent attacks were described by CNN as a “hit-and-miss missile blitz.”

    In a similar vein, investigators from Bellingcat, an investigative journalism group based in the Netherlands and founded by a British journalist in 2014, recently claimed to have uncovered a network of Russian military operatives, who they say are responsible for planning and laying out flight paths for high-precision cruise missiles targeting Ukrainian cities and infrastructure.

    Referencing Russia’s latest series of missile strikes, Christo Grozev, the author of the report, tweeted on November 15: “Russia fired 100 missiles at Ukraine today, hitting a residential building in Kyiv and leaving whole cities without electricity. These young men and women were inputting the missile flight paths, again.”

    However, even as Russia appears to have a track record of faulty missile navigation, there is little evidence to suggest that was the case in Poland. While the investigation into the strike continues, the current consensus appears to be that it was not a Russian missile.

    As Polish President Andrzej Duda and other officials have said, the explosion was likely an accident resulting from a Ukraine air defense missile being used against Russian rockets.

    NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg echoed this sentiment.

    “Our preliminary analysis suggests that the incident was likely caused by the Ukrainian air defense missile fired to defend Ukrainian territory against Russian cruise missile attacks,” Stoltenberg said in a statement on November 16.

    “But let me be clear, this is not Ukraine’s fault. Russia bears ultimate responsibility, as it continues its illegal war against Ukraine.”

    Proving whether Russian operatives could have made a “typo” in inputting coordinates intended for either Kyiv or Lviv would be extremely difficult. Not only would Russia have to admit fault in the incident (which the Russian foreign ministry has blamed on Ukraine), but it would separately also have to confirm that faulty navigation was behind it.

    Newsweek was unable to find any other evidence to support the theory on social media. While the partial match of coordinates does seem to be a surprising coincidence, in the absence of substantive proof it remains just that—a coincidence.

    Whatever may have caused the missile strike in Przewodów, there is not, at present, enough publicly-available evidence to determine that the strike was the result of a typographical error, nor that Russia was behind it.

    The investigation into the incident is ongoing, with reports from the local media indicating that Ukrainian authorities and experts will not be allowed to take part.

    “The information we have received from the Ukrainian side is of very significant importance to us. However, it is certain that Ukraine, just like any other country, will not be the co-host of the investigation, because this is our, Polish investigation,” Paweł Soloch, an adviser to Polish President Andrzej Duda, told local broadcaster Radio Plus in an interview.

    Newsweek has contacted the Kremlin and the Ukrainian government for comment.

    The Ruling

    Unverified.

    Kyiv and Lviv have similar map coordinates with Przewodów, which, in theory, could have been the basis for the missile strike on the Polish village near the border of Ukraine.

    However, there is no further evidence available to support this claim.

    While the Ukrainian president initially blamed Russia for the strike, NATO and Poland appear to have formed a consensus that it was likely an accident caused by Ukraine’s anti-air missile defenses.

    FACT CHECK BY Newsweek’s Fact Check team

    Related Articles

    Start your unlimited Newsweek trial

    Leave a Reply