England head home from World Cup rueing another penalty miss

The scourge of missed penalties returned to haunt England last night as their World Cup dreams ended in familiar scenes of tears and shattered dreams.

At the final whistle, as players slumped to the turf and hands covered their faces, the abiding memory was of Gareth Southgate comforting his captain Harry Kane. It was Kane who had the chance to equalise this pulsating quarter-final against France when, with England 2-1 down, he stepped forward from 12 yards out.

But when he blazed over, you could hear the howls of anguish reverberate all the way from Doha to London. The tears of these England players will soon subside. But the sting of this loss will surely linger.

“As you’d expect he is very, very low, but he has got nothing to reproach himself for,” said Southgate afterwards. “We are in the position we are as a team because of his leadership and goals.”

And, as if to anticipate the morning tabloid headlines, Southgate then added: “No recriminations, the players have been brilliant and we win and lose as a team.”

What made his defeat hurt even more was that this World Cup reeked of enticing possibilities. England’s management team have always believed that France would be their biggest block to glory here in Qatar. But they knew that if they won they would face Morocco, who were 300-1 underdogs before the tournament, in the semi-finals.

We are constantly being told there are no easy games at international level. But Southgate would have taken that before the tournament.

Olivier Giroud heads home France’s winner. Photograph: Richard Sellers/Getty Images

As it was, there was so much here for England to be proud about as they went toe-to-toe with the world champions for 90 minutes. They were bold, they were inventive. They pushed forward in a style that shed their familiar conservatism.

And, at times, it seemed that all sorts of enticing possibilities were opening up, especially after Kane’s penalty early in the second half equalised Aurélien Tchouaméni’s early thunderbolt.

But in a final 15 minutes laced with impossible tension, Oliver Giroud put France 2-1 ahead – and then for Kane to miss a second penalty that would have probably sent the tie into extra time.

“The players know how close they have come,” admitted Southgate. “They know they have pushed a top nation all the way. More possession. More shots on goal. I am very proud of how they have been. But tonight we have come up short. We felt we could win the tournament.”

Since England’s sole World Cup triumph in 1966 their results in the knockout stages have followed a simple repetitive formula: they lose to the first powerhouse they face. And so it proved. But there was no shame in this defeat.

Quick Guide England’s World Cup quarter-final exits Show

Defeat to France in Al Khor means England have lost seven World Cup quarter-finals, having only reached the final four three times – in 1966, when they went on to win the trophy, and in 1990 and 2018.

1954: lost 4-2 to Uruguay Nat Lofthouse and Tom Finney scored for England but the reigning champions punished Gil Merrick’s goalkeeping errors in Switzerland

1958: lost 3-1 to Brazil Pelé’s absence gave England hope in Chile but Garrincha’s two goals saw the eventual champions through

1970: lost 3-2 to West Germany Alf Ramsey’s side let slip a two-goal lead as Gerd Müller struck in extra time to end England’s title defence

1986: lost 2-1 to Argentina Diego Maradona followed up the ‘Hand of God’ with one of the greatest solo goals ever as Argentina prevailed

2002: lost 2-1 to Brazil Michael Owen fired England in front but Rivaldo’s leveller and Ronaldinho’s long-range lob turned the tide

2006: lost to Portugal on penalties after 0-0 draw Wayne Rooney was sent off as England’s golden generation fell short

2022: lost 2-1 to France After falling short of the last eight in South Africa and Brazil, and going beyond it in Russia, England suffer a seventh quarter-final exit against the defending champions

Thank you for your feedback.

Questions had lingered about Southgate’s tactics in the biggest games, when the stakes are so high even a Vegas high-roller might blink. England had been 1-0 up against Croatia in the 2018 World Cup semi-finals, and again against Italy in the Euro 2020 final, only to concede ground and, eventually, the game. Not this time.

It was a sign of Southgate’s confidence that he kept the same team of players that beat Senegal in the last 16, lined up in a 4-3-3 formation. Initially, however, they were too cautious and deservedly went behind after 17 minutes. But the blow came early enough to shake England out of their lethargy. And they responded magnificently.

Sign up to Football Daily

Kick off your evenings with the Guardian’s take on the world of football

Privacy Notice: Newsletters may contain info about charities, online ads, and content funded by outside parties. For more information see our Privacy Policy. We use Google reCaptcha to protect our website and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

There were signs before Kane eventually equalised that England were controlling the middle eight of this game, with France’s keeper Hugo Lloris having to push away a deflected Kane shot. And when, early in the second half, Tchouaméni hung out a leg and brought Bukayo Saka down, England were deservedly level from the penalty spot.

The game was opening up, becoming looser and more ragged. But as the match entered the final 15 minutes, France found a second wind. England were given ample warning of what was to come when Giroud shot at Pickford from eight yards when it seemed easy to score. But moments later, the striker smashed home what turned out to be the winner.

There was to be one more twist – and turn of the knife. Almost immediately Theo Hernandez unnecessarily barged into Mason Mount and VAR rightly ruled it to be a penalty. This time, though, Kane could not maintain his composure and blasted over the bar.

Harry Kane’s England record

Now French eyes turn to Morocco, whose manager, Walid Regragui, compared his team to Rocky Balboa after they stunned Portugal 1-0. That run here in Qatar is all the more remarkable as they were among the outsiders at the start of the tournament, while Regragui has only been in post since August.

“I think we are becoming the team that everyone loves in this World Cup because we are showing the world that you can achieve even if you don’t have as much talent, as much quality, as much money,” he said.

Morocco’s run here in Qatar is all the more remarkable were among the outsiders at the start of the tournament. However, the Atlas Lions have since topped a group that included Croatia and Belgium, and then beat Spain and Portugal.

Along the way he has also created a strong sense of unity with an unusual tactic: by inviting the player’s mothers into the camp. “If you work hard enough and you show that desire, that passion and belief then you can succeed. It’s no miracle.”

England, meanwhile, will have to pick up the pieces of another torturous defeat. It will be scant consolation that they pushed the world champions all the way.